- Mar 13
- 2 min read
My Rating: 4/5 stars 🍋🍋🍋🍋☕
Spiciness: 0/5 🌶️ (Spice-free!)

First off, I want to say thank you so much to JD Millar for an advanced copy of Murder in Sicily!
A small town with ancient roots - a fragrant tea steeped in the waters of rich history. Marisa Leone is an American trying to start over in Sicily, a town that seems as desperate to accuse her of murder as it is vibrant in its rustic Italian aesthetics. A cast of colorful characters - including LGBTQ+ representation (though I won’t say who!) - makes this cozy mystery all the more intriguing.
My mystery background music married with the thunderstorms outside created the perfect backdrop to cloak myself up in a blanket, armed with a latte and freshly baked shortbread cookies, and transport to the sunny town of Sicily.
I found myself quickly connecting to Marisa, becoming invested in her growth as a character and easily imagining myself in her place. I have a feeling some might complain about her struggles with self-esteem - but I think JD Millar did a fantastic job of capturing the reality of living with anxiety and chronic people-pleasing behavior (and did I detect a hint of Moral OCD? Ah, she just reminds me so much of myself.)
Speaking of relatability, the developing tension between Marisa and the MMC Angelo scratches all those little slow burn itches for me. Lingering gazes, fresh banter, and frankly adorable moments made me invested throughout the entire book. As tensions mounted - and not just between the FMC and MMC - the story had me putting off work just to find out… who killed Carla di Monterosso?
And JD Millar doesn’t make it easy to find out! So many little clues throughout the book that you’ll have lots of fun trying to piece together. Now, while I greatly enjoyed the ride, the ending of the book wasn’t everything that I had expected. It hasn’t deterred me from wanting to read the next books, though!
The entire book felt like a trip to Italy, complete with bite-sized lessons on the Italian language and history. I was reminded of the old Nancy Drew PC games, particularly A Phantom in Venice - so the cozy factor was ever-present for me!
Overall, this book receives a solid 4 stars (or in this case, lemons!) for me! I would highly recommend it if you are a fan of cozy mystery and slow burn romance.
Ciao!
About the Author
JD Millar

JD Millar writes character-driven mysteries with a splash of danger, a dash of humor, and settings you’ll wish to visit.
Originally from Europe and often on the move, she draws inspiration from historic towns, sunlit coastlines, and the interesting people who live there. When she’s not writing, she’s usually traveling, reading, or plotting the next mystery over a cup of tea.
Where to find JD Millar:
Linktree: https://linktr.ee/jdmillar
Insta: @jdmillarauthor
TikTok: @jdmillarauthor


